Improving the Processes of Classification and Declassification

DOI: 10.33917/es-6.204.2025.134-143

The article proposes to examine a preliminary version of a program for improving methodological tools for increasing the level of objectivity when making decisions on classifying or declassifying information. The program consists of several stages, which include: conducting preliminary work, including collecting information and solving specially formulated problems, solution of which would facilitate the implementation of these stages; collecting additional information and solving the assigned problems; analyzing the information received and solving the problems that arise; ensuring ongoing monitoring of the implementation effectiveness of the proposed program. A total of 32 such problems are formulated. Furthermore, the authors discuss ways to improve methodological principles and methodological tools in this area. In conclusion, the authors present a plan for future research in the above area.

References:

1. Sagan C. The Demon-Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark. Ballantine Book. New York, 1996, 457 p.

2. Zakon Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 21.07.93 N 5485-1 “O gosudarstvennoy tayne” (v red. federal’nykh zakonov ot 06.10.97 N 131-FZ, ot 30.06.2003 N 86-FZ, ot 11.11.2003 N 153-FZ, ot 29.06.2004 N 58-FZ, ot 22.08.2004 N 122-FZ, ot 01.12.2007 N 294-FZ, ot 01.12.2007 N 318-FZ, ot 18.07.2009 N 180-FZ, ot 15.11.2010 N 299-FZ, ot 18.07.2011 N 242-FZ, ot 19.07.2011 N 248-FZ, ot 08.11.2011 N 309-FZ, ot 21.12.2013 N 377-FZ, ot 08.03.2015 N 23-FZ, ot 26.07.2017 N 193-FZ, ot 29.07.2018 N 256-FZ, ot 30.12.2020 N 481-FZ, ot 09.03.2021 N 39-FZ, ot 11.06.2021 N 170-FZ, ot 14.07.2022 N 292-FZ, ot 04.08.2022 N 359-FZ, ot 05.12.2022 N 498-FZ, ot 04.08.2023 N 432-FZ, ot 08.08.2024 N 249-FZ) [Law of the Russian Federation of 21.07.93 No. 5485-1 “On State Secrets” (as amended by federal laws of 06.10.97 No. 131-FZ, of 30.06.2003 No. 86-FZ, of 11.11.2003 No. 153-FZ, of 29.06.2004 No. 58-FZ, of 22.08.2004 No. 122-FZ, of 01.12.2007 No. 294-FZ, of 01.12.2007 No. 318-FZ, of 18.07.2009 No. 180-FZ, of 15.11.2010 No. 299-FZ, dated 18.07.2011 No. 242-FZ, dated 19.07.2011 No. 248-FZ, of 08.11.2011 No. 309-FZ, of 21.12.2013 No. 377-FZ, of 08.03.2015 No. 23-FZ, of 26.07.2017 No. 193-FZ, of 29.07.2018 No. 256-FZ, of 30.12.2020 No. 481-FZ, of 09.03.2021 No. 39-FZ, of 11.06.2021 No. 170-FZ, of 14.07.2022 No. 292-FZ, of 04.08.2022 No. 359-FZ, of 05.12.2022 No. 498-FZ, dated 04.08.2023 No. 432-FZ, dated 08.08.2024 No. 249-FZ)]. Konsul’tantPlyus, available at: https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_2481/

3. Veryutin V.N. Otdel’nye aspekty zashchity gosudarstvennoy tayny v Rossiyskoy Federatsii [Certain Aspects of the Protection of State Secrets in the Russian Federation]. Vestnik Voronezhskogo instituta MVD Rossii, 2009, no 2, pp. 17–22.

4. Kotov M.A., Kravchenko A.Yu., Chervonenko V.Yu. Ob opredelenii ekonomicheskogo ushcherba bezopasnosti gosudarstva vsledstvie nesanktsionirovannogo raskrytiya svedeniy, sostavlyayushchikh gosudarstvennuyu taynu v VS RF [On the Determination of Economic Damage to State Security Due to the Unauthorized Disclosure of Information Constituting a State Secret in the RF Armed Forces]. Voennaya mysl’, 2009, no 6, pp. 21–26.

5. Sidel’nikov Yu.V. Analiz traktovok klyuchevogo ponyatiya “Metodologiya”: XII Vserossiyskoe soveshchanie po problemam upravleniya VSPU-2014: Sb. trudov konferentsii. Moskva, 16–19 iyulya 2014 g. [Analysis of Interpretations of the Key Concept “Methodology”: XII All-Russian Conference on Management Problems VSPU-2014: Conference Proceedings. Moscow, July 16–19, 2014.]. Moscow, Izd-vo Instituta problem upravleniya imeni V.A. Trapeznikova RAN, 2014, pp. 7861–7864.

6. Sidel’nikov Yu.V. Formirovanie ponyatiyno-terminologicheskogo apparata ekspertologii [Formation of the Conceptual and Terminological Apparatus of Expertology]. Problemy upravleniya, 2017, no 5, pp. 18–30.

7. Sidel’nikov Yu.V. Sistemnyy analiz tekhnologii ekspertnogo prognozirovaniya [System Analysis of Expert Forecasting Technology]. Moscow, Izd-vo MAI-PRINT, 2007, 348 p.

8. Pelipenko A.A. K probleme slozhnosti [On the Complexity Problem]. Ekonomicheskie strategii, 2014, vol. 16, no 1, pp. 90–95.

9. Pelipenko A.A. K probleme slozhnosti [On the Complexity Problem]. Ekonomicheskie strategii, 2014, vol. 16, no 2, pp. 124–133.

10. Vysotskiy V.S. K osnovaniyam teorii izmereniy: Ekspertnye metody v sistemnykh issledovaniyakh [Towards the Foundations of Measurement Theory: Expert Methods in Systems Research]. Moscow, VNIISI, 1979, Vyp. 4, pp. 84–95.

11. Podinovskiy V.V. Vvedenie v teoriyu vazhnosti kriteriev v mnogokriterial’nykh zadachakh prinyatiya resheniy [Introduction to the Theory of Criteria Importance in Multicriteria Decision-Making Problems]. Moscow, Fizmatlit, 2007, 64 p.

12. Podinovskiy V.V. Analiz zadach mnogokriterial’nogo vybora metodami teorii vazhnosti kriteriev pri pomoshchi komp’yuternykh sistem podderzhki prinyatiya resheniy [Analysis of Multi-Criteria Choice Problems Using Criteria Importance Theory Methods with the Help of Computer Decision Support Systems]. Izvestiya Rossiyskoy akademii nauk. Teoriya i sistemy upravleniya, 2008, no 2, pp. 64–68.

13. Podinovskiy V.V., Nogin V.D. Pareto-optimal’nye resheniya mnogokriterial’nykh zadach [Pareto-optimal Solutions to Multicriteria Problems]. Moscow, Nauka, 1982, 258 p.

14. Saltykov S.A. Eksperimental’noe sopostavlenie metodov vzveshennoy summy, teorii poleznosti i teorii vazhnosti kriteriev dlya resheniya mnogokriterial’nykh zadach s ball’nymi kriteriyami: Upravlenie bol’shimi sistemami [Experimental Comparison of Weighted Sum Methods, Utility Theory and Criteria Importance Theory for Solving Multicriteria Problems with Scoring Criteria: Management of Large Systems]. Moscow, 2010, no 29, pp. 16–41.

15. Saltykov S.A. Snizhenie zatrat na postroenie funktsii tsennosti pri ispol’zovanii reshayushchikh pravil teorii vazhnosti kriteriev po sravneniyu s traditsionnym podkhodom teorii poleznosti: Upravlenie bol’shimi sistemami [Reducing the Cost of Constructing a Value Function Using the Decision Rules of the Criterion Importance Theory Compared to the Traditional Approach of Utility Theory]. Moscow, 2011, no 34, pp. 5–29.

16. Saltykov S.A., Rusyaeva E.Yu. Rafinirovanie nauchnykh postroeniy v teoriyakh prinyatiya resheniy [Refining Scientific Constructs in Decision-making Theories]. Moscow, Izd-vo Instituta problem upravleniya imeni V.A. Trapeznikova RAN, 2016, 208 p.

17. Lemtyuzhnikova D.V., Leonov V.Y. Large-scale problems with quasi-block matrices. Journal of Computer and Systems Sciences International, 2019, vol. 58, No. 4, pp. 571–578.

18. Shcherbina O.A., Lemtyuzhnikova D.V., Tsurkov V.I. Mnogomernye zadachi s kvaziblochnymi matritsami [Multidimensional Problems with Quasi-block Matrices]. Moscow, Fizmatlit, 2018, 256 p.

19. Kini R.L., Rayfa Kh. Prinyatie resheniy pri mnogikh kriteriyakh: predpochteniya i zameshcheniya [Multicriteria Decision Making: Preferences and Substitutions]. Pod red. I.F. Shakhnova; Per. s angl. V.V. Podinovskogo, et al. Moscow, Radio i svyaz’, 1981, 560 p.

20. Saltykov S.A., Rusyaeva E.Yu. Mnogokriterial’nyy otbor: rafinirovanie modeli [Multicriterial Selection: Model Refining]. Ekonomicheskie strategii, 2016, vol. 18, no 5(139), pp. 160–173.

21. GOST 23554.2-81. Ekspertnye metody otsenki kachestva promyshlennoy produktsii. Obrabotka znacheniy ekspertnykh otsenok kachestva produktsii [GOST 23554.2-81. Expert methods for assessing the quality of industrial products. Processing expert assessments of product quality.]. Moscow, Izd-vo standartov, 1982.

22. Krylov E.M. Strukturno-analiticheskie modeli, algoritmy i programmnoe obespechenie klassifikatsionnoy obrabotki dannykh v prostranstve rangovykh otsenok dlya avtomatizatsii prinyatiya resheniy: Avtoref. dis. … kand. tekhn. nauk [Structural-analytical Models, Algorithms and Software for Classification Data Processing in the Space of Rank Estimates for Automated Decision-making: Abstract of a PhD thesis]. Khar’kov, KhIR, 1984.

23. Sidel’nikov Yu.V., Bukhalov V.A. Protsedura utochneniya postanovki zadachi na razrabotku proektov naukoemkoy produktsii (na primere aviatsionnoy tekhniki) [The Procedure for Refining the Formulation of the Task for the Development of High-tech Product Projects (Using Aviation Technology as an Example)]. Vestnik Moskovskogo aviatsionnogo institute, 2009, vol. 16, no 4, pp. 95–100.

24. Sidel’nikov Yu.V., Kalmykov N.S. Metody postanovki ekspertnykh zadach i ikh korrektirovki [Methods for Setting Expert Tasks and Adjusting Them]. Ekonomika i upravlenie v mashinostroenii, 2017, no 5, pp. 59–64.

25. Andreeva G.M. Sotsial’naya psikhologiya [Social Psychology]. Moscow, Nauka, 1994, 325 p.

26. Krichevskiy R.L., Dubovskaya E.M. Sotsial’naya psikhologiya maloy gruppy [Social Psychology of a Small Group]. Ucheb. posobie dlya vuzov. M.: Aspekt Press, 2001. 318 s.

27. Cartwright D., Zander A. (Eds.) Group dynamics. Research and Theory. New York, 1968, 580 p.

28. Sidel’nikov Yu.V., Ryapukhin A.V. Povyshenie effektivnosti soveshchaniy v malykh gruppakh. Ch. 1. Traditsionnye podkhody k problem [Improving the Effectiveness of Small Group Meetings: Part 1: Traditional Approaches]. Problemy upravleniya, 2018, no 6, pp. 18–23.

29. Sidel’nikov Yu.V., Ryapukhin A.V. Povyshenie effektivnosti soveshchaniy v malykh gruppakh. Ch. 2. Nestandartnye podkhody k problem [Improving the Effectiveness of Small Group Meetings: Part 2: Creative Approaches]. Problemy upravleniya, 2019, no 1, pp. 15–25.

30. Sidel’nikov Yu.V., Ryapukhin A.V. Perspektivy issledovaniya v oblasti povysheniya effektivnosti soveshchaniy [Research Prospects for Improving Meeting Effectiveness]. Zavodskaya laboratoriya. Diagnostika materialov, 2019, vol. 85, no 5, pp. 80–86.